U.S. President Donald Trump is persisting in his quest for Venezuela’s oil wealth, unveiling a new agreement designed to enhance production in the South American nation. While Trump is showcasing the prospective controlling interest in a segment of Venezuela’s oil reserves as a cautionary note to Canada, analysts indicate there is minimal reason for alarm in Western Canada.
A rise in Venezuelan oil shipments to refineries along the U.S. Gulf Coast could create competition for the Alberta oil sector, given that both regions produce a similar grade of heavy oil.
Although Venezuela possesses some of the world’s largest subterranean oil reserves, the country grapples with numerous obstacles to increasing output, including political turmoil that could thwart any efforts to revitalize its oil sector.
Concurrently, the Canadian oil industry continues to achieve new production records, alongside several new and expanding pipeline initiatives at various stages of development designed to enhance export capacity. Despite the ongoing trade conflict, the U.S. is progressively increasing its consumption of Canadian oil, which constituted over 60 percent of the nation’s crude oil imports last year.
Experts assert that a significant increase in Venezuelan oil exports is still five to ten years away, which is why any potential threat to Canada is not an immediate concern, according to Grant Sprague, a former deputy energy minister in Alberta.
“If the Americans want to pursue this, they will have to invest considerable time and resources,” Sprague remarked, discussing the agreement between the U.S. and Venezuela.
“One of the things we do know is that we don’t know a whole lot about it,” he added.
The new ‘deal’
On Friday, Trump took to social media to announce that his administration had secured a deal with Venezuela for majority control of one-fifth of the nation’s oil reserves. Under this agreement, the U.S. will acquire a direct equity interest in a private company led by a Venezuelan entrepreneur.
Trump stated that this arrangement would significantly enhance the U.S. oil supply and secure majority control over 65 billion barrels of oil reserves. In response, Venezuela’s acting president Delcy Rodríguez noted that the deal would attract tens of billions of dollars in investments while preserving the country’s “ownership and sovereignty” over its natural resources.
The two messages are “significantly different,” remarked Al Salazar, a Calgary-based analyst with Enverus, an energy analytics firm.
“There’s some inconsistency regarding what’s transpiring. It does give you pause,” he stated. “Nobody has clarity on the terms at this point.”
This uncertainty is partly why Canadian oil executives are paying attention to the deal, although they are not overly worried. Instead, they will monitor any tangible advancements in revitalizing the struggling Venezuelan industry.
“Show me the barrel first before anyone makes a move,” he noted about the sentiment within the Canadian sector.
The Trump administration has been encouraging U.S. oil and gas executives to invest in Venezuela’s energy sector following a military operation that captured then-president Nicolás Maduro in January.
Oilsands decades ahead
Most of Canada’s heavy oil is sourced from the oilsands region in Northern Alberta, where mining and industrial operations yield millions of barrels daily and have evolved into one of the most cost-effective sources of oil in North America.
One of the significant advantages of the oilsands is that the multi-billion dollar facilities are fully constructed, paid off, and continually upgraded, according to Alex Filstein, a technology developer and reservoir engineer in the oilsands.
“We don’t need to invest more in facilities. We simply produce that oil. We just operate those facilities. We enjoy political stability and maintain a very low cost of supply in Canada,” stated Filstein, who serves as the chief technology officer at Watercut Inc.
This stands in stark contrast to Venezuela, which, during its peak in 1970, produced 3.7 million barrels per day.

Suncor’s Fort Hills oilsands mine cost about $17 billion to construct and began operating in 2018. (Kyle Bakx/CBC)
Last year, the country could only extract approximately 900,000 barrels per day due to many years of reduced investments stemming from sanctions and ineffective government policies.
Experts argue that not only is the oil industry infrastructure in various states of disrepair and neglect, but it is also uncertain how much funding will be needed for repairs, let alone for new infrastructure development.
“Nobody really knows the condition of these facilities,” asserted Filstein, who characterizes the vague information and uncertainty in Venezuela as a significant barrier for major U.S. energy firms that might hesitate to invest there. These companies may prefer to allocate their investments elsewhere globally.
“Firms require stability and need to be assured of how the funds are managed,” Filstein explained.
Political hurdles
In addition to practical challenges, political instability is also a factor.
If Venezuela’s oil sector truly recovers, by that time, both the U.S. and Venezuela may have different leaders and possibly new administrations as well.
“There’s an open question about whether a future government in Venezuela would uphold this deal when the country returns to democracy. For companies contemplating investment, there are significant financial risks as well as substantial political risks involved,” remarked Colin Mang, an economics professor at McMaster University in Hamilton.
“It’s uncertain whether American oil firms will invest, at least not to the degree that the Trump administration anticipates,” he noted.
Historically, foreign companies have had their Venezuelan assets expropriated, with ExxonMobil facing this issue twice.
Currently, a few companies, including Shell and Repsol, have shown interest in potential new investments in Venezuela’s oil and gas sector. Chevron, already operating in the country, is considering an expansion.
The possibility of increased heavy oil imports into the U.S. is not something Canada should fear, according to Sprague, the former Alberta deputy energy minister.
He highlights that global oil demand continues to rise and Canada is ramping up its exports from the West Coast to international markets such as China and India.
The Trans Mountain pipeline system, which transports oil from Edmonton to the Vancouver area, is currently operating at full capacity, and an initial expansion is anticipated to be finished by year-end.
The Alberta government is also collaborating with the federal government to develop a new pipeline project along a similar route. The federal authorities are expected to make a decision by October 1 on whether to classify the proposal as a “project of national interest” under the Building Canada Act.
“The United States seeks a variety of sources. That’s acceptable. We are also considering a variety of markets,” Sprague stated.


